While the objectives of promoting transformation, ensuring environmental sustainability, and enhancing regulatory efficiency are widely acknowledged, the proposed means to achieve these goals have raised concerns about increased regulatory uncertainty, potential deterrents to investment, and practical implementation challenges.

Addressing these issues through comprehensive consultation and careful legislative drafting will be essential to balance the interests of economic development, environmental stewardship, and social equity in South Africa's mining sector.

Webber Wentzel has highlighted potential legislative changes indicated in South Africa's Exploration Strategy, published in April 2022. The strategy suggests amendments to the MPRDA, including extending timelines for prospecting rights and revising the "first come, first served" principle in favour of a merit-based system.

While these changes aim to enhance investment appeal, they raise concerns about increased uncertainty and potential corruption. Giada Masina, a partner at Webber Wentzel, emphasized that such amendments could lead to ambiguity regarding licensing criteria and elevate the risk of unethical practices.

Furthermore, Webber Wentzel has expressed reservations about the Upstream Petroleum Resources Development Bill (UPRDB), which seeks to separate oil and gas regulations from mining. The firm points to concerns over the proposed 20% carried interest for the state and a mandatory 10% participation for historically disadvantaged South Africans (HDSAs). Jonathan Veeran, a partner at Webber Wentzel, cautioned that these provisions might deter potential investors due to the substantial financial commitments required in the oil and gas sector.

The Minerals Council South Africa, representing a significant portion of the country's mineral production, has also voiced apprehensions regarding potential amendments to the MPRDA. CEO Mzila Mthenjane acknowledged concerns about the government's intent to address issues like the "once empowered, always empowered" principle through legislative changes. While specific amendments remain uncertain, Mthenjane noted that discussions with the Department of Mineral Resources and Energy (DMRE) have been constructive.

RELATED: DMPR releases Critical Minerals Strategy, and amended MPRDA

The Council has emphasized the importance of a regulatory environment that encourages investment in exploration and ensures policy consistency. In a set of recommendations aimed at revitalizing investment in South African mining, they advocated for a coherent and efficient regulatory system, streamlined administrative processes, and a review of the MPRDA and Mining Charter to align local ownership requirements with international best practices.

Both Webber Wentzel and the Minerals Council South Africa underscore the necessity for careful consideration of any amendments to the MPRDA. Their insights highlight the delicate balance required to promote transformation and economic growth while maintaining a stable and attractive investment climate.

Engaging with industry stakeholders and addressing their concerns will be crucial in shaping a legislative framework that supports the sustainable development of South Africa's mineral and petroleum resources.
 

Join Us at Mining Indaba 2026

Mining Indaba 2026 is where African and global mining leaders come together to connect and shape the future. Exhibit, sponsor, or register your interest today—don’t miss out!

Exhibit or Sponsor  Register Interest